(Why Do Only White People Get Abducted by Aliens?) PDF ó Ilana Garon
READ ç PDF, DOC, TXT or eBook Ì Ilana Garon
READ ç PDF, DOC, TXT or eBook Ì Ilana Garon READ & DOWNLOAD Æ Why Do Only White People Get Abducted by Aliens? According to Ilana Garon popular books and movies are inundated with the myth of the “hero teacher” the one who charges headfirst into dysfunctional inner city schools like a firefighter into an inferno bringing the student victims to safety through a combination of charisma and innate righteousness The students are then “saved” by the teacher’s idealism empathy and willingness to put faith in kids who have been given up on by society as a whole “Why Do Only White People Get Abducted by Aliens” is not that type of bookIn this book Garon reveals the sometime. Ilana Garon and I have similar educational backgrounds We were both Barnard undergraduates and both received teaching degrees and a Masters in Creative Writing But here s one difference between us If I had been placed in a Bronx inner city public school I would ve fled without uestion Garon she stayedI say this not to bring my personal capabilities to bear on this review but to state something larger that though Garon had every reason to feel overwhelmed and intimidated by her environment she white naive and inexperienced they prone to violence race riots and epithets she stayed putFrom the outset Garon dispels the Hollywood notion of the teaching memoir wherein an idealistic instructor plunges into an inner city school to save failing children This is not that kind of book she deadpans Except I would argue that it is Because just by being there she saves them just by laughing with them scolding them imploring them and attempting to affect themGaron cites her age she is 22 at the start as a hindrance but it may have been her greatest asset Implicitly she knows she must level with her students it is the only way her words will process She must play their games take their bait and see them as whole children Inevitably she spies potential in many of them but she never has any illusions about their chances for success After all theirs is a school with depleted resources uninvolved parents and disruptive truant children Many of their home lives come with a new slew of issues jail time teen pregnancy gang violence broken familiesit is all routineBut what of it As Garon says There will be class in the morning She has To Kill a Mockingbird Animal Farm and Shakespeare to teach Essays uizzes and group work to oversee To spend a disproportionate amount of time bemoaning the circumstances would be a disservice to her students So Garon does the only thing she can do for them She shows up She tries to teach them She cares And for her efforts there are several crystallized moments of sweetnessAliens is broken up into four sections to correspond with Garon s first four years of teaching Within them are chapters headed by the names of former students call them case studies character sketches or human interest pieces There are also e mails which she sends to friends and family members emotional outlets for her bizarre experiences The emails dotted throughout were perhaps my favorite part Who can resist Garon unguarded and ever the storyteller as she regales us with these outlandish tales Think the Weird but True section in the New York Post Do you her students are always telling her And she does hereGaron s writing like her teaching style is direct and matter of fact She writes in service of the story rather than the sentence She does not pass judgment but simply tells over events as they happened The stories speak for themselves and if there are any conclusions to be drawn they are the reader s to makeOn the one hand I thought this an admirable approach too easily Garon could ve fallen into the trap of denouncing students letting her frustration and exhaustion take over her exposition Though there are moments where she does break down mostly she shows tremendous reserve Still I wish she would ve gone there dug deep reached down As a reader I was always second guessing myself wondering if I d gotten what she d wanted me to out of an escapade Yes we don t like to be spoon fed but we do want to feel in syncGaron saves her reflection for the very end where in a single chapter she extemporizes upon the state of NYC public school education the things that can be changed and those that have no choice but to stay the same She comes off lofty and didactic in this pages in fact the tone here is markedly different from the rest of the book and I wondered if the chapter was belatedly tacked on Though perhaps it could only appear at the end for only after serenading us with tales of her ten year teaching career does she have the credibility to write it Why Do Only White People Get Abducted by Aliens is an uncensored look at inner city education It is about a young teacher coming of age with her students as she tries incrementally to make a differencethis review originally appeared on ReadLatelycom
FREE DOWNLOAD Why Do Only White People Get Abducted by Aliens?
READ ç PDF, DOC, TXT or eBook Ì Ilana Garon READ & DOWNLOAD Æ Why Do Only White People Get Abducted by Aliens? T with them big dreams and uncommon insight and challenged everything Garon thought she knew about educationIn response Garon a naive suburban girl with a curly ponytail freckles and Harry Potter glasses opened her eyes rolled up her sleeves and learned to distinguish between mitigated failure and ualified success In this book Garon explains how she learned that being a new teacher was about trial by fire making mistakes learning from the very students she was teaching and occasionally admitting that she may not have answers to their thought provoking and amusing uestion. I have enjoyed Ms Garon s blogs so I decided to read her book accounting her first years of teaching I also teach English in what is considered an inner city school Our experiences share many similarities but I think her students deal with issues than mine I started teaching later in life I could not imagine being in that situation fresh out of college I could relate to apathetic students who barely turn in work and the frustration felt when promising students seem to sabotage themselves I believe somewhere in the book it stated that we can t save them all Remember this This book is important because it is a first hand account of what is going on in low SES schools Those who think Common Core standardized testing andor the best teachers can FIX schools SpEd ELLs be damned need to know that there is no silver bullet Kidsschools are not one size fits all Ms Garon did the best she could with her students with all the best of intentions She made connections with students and showed them she cared Even with all the negatives she still teaches in the Bronx We need teachers like herREAD ç PDF, DOC, TXT or eBook Ì Ilana Garon
READ ç PDF, DOC, TXT or eBook Ì Ilana Garon READ & DOWNLOAD Æ Why Do Only White People Get Abducted by Aliens? S humorous oftentimes frustrating and occasionally horrifying truths that accompany the experience of teaching at a public high school in the Bronx today The overcrowded classrooms lack of textbooks and abundance of mice cockroaches and drugs weren’t the only challenges Garon faced during her first four years as a teacher Every day she’d interact with students such as Kayron Carlos Felicia Jonah Elizabeth and Tonya students dealing with real life addictions miscarriages stints in “juvie” abusive relationships turf wars and gang violence These students also brough. Interesting book A different side of education